Student Handout · Grades 9–12

Old Lies, New Words

A sorting sheet: ten statements, three columns, one question.
Teach Jewish History · Unit 3 & Unit 6 companion · C3 D2.His.14, D2.Civ.14

Ask one question of each statement: is it about a government’s policies, or is it an old lie about Jews in a new costume?

Two words to know

Zionism is the movement for Jewish national self-determination in the Land of Israel: the idea that the Jewish people, like other peoples, are entitled to a state of their own. Anti-Zionism is opposition to that idea. Disagreeing with a government is not the same as saying the country should not exist.

The ten statements

  1. “Israel should stop building settlements in the West Bank.”
  2. “Israelis take the organs of Palestinians.”
  3. “Israel should not exist.”
  4. “Jews control Hollywood and the news.”
  5. “The United States should not fund Israel’s military.”
  6. “American Jews are more loyal to Israel than to America.”
  7. “Zionism is racism.”
  8. “Israel’s government handled the war in Gaza badly.”
  9. “Jewish students here should answer for what Israel does.”
  10. “Israel is doing what the Nazis did.”

Sort them

Write each letter in the column where it belongs. If the class cannot agree on one, write it under the table and say why.

Criticism of a governmentCalling for the end of IsraelAn old lie about Jews

We could not agree on:

Exit ticket. Write one sentence that criticizes a government’s policy and uses none of the old charges.

Teacher Key

Old Lies, New Words: the key

Where each statement belongs, and why.
ColumnStatementsWhy
Criticism of a governmentA, E, HEach names a policy or a decision and says it should change. The three widely used definitions of antisemitism all protect criticism of Israel’s policies, leaders, and laws.
Calling for the end of IsraelC, GEach rejects the state itself. This is the column where the three definitions differ. The IHRA definition lists denying the Jewish people the right to self-determination as possible antisemitism, depending on context. The Jerusalem Declaration calls it antisemitic to deny “the right of Jews in the State of Israel to exist and flourish, collectively and individually, as Jews.” Let the class argue this column.
An old lie about JewsB, D, F, IB is the blood libel, first recorded at Norwich in 1144. D is the claim of secret control, the template of the forged Protocols of 1903. F is the charge of disloyalty. I holds Jews everywhere responsible for what a government does, which both the IHRA definition and the Jerusalem Declaration list as antisemitism.
For the class to argueJThe IHRA definition lists “drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis” among its examples of what antisemitism could include, taking the context into account. The three definitions treat this comparison differently.

Background to read aloud

Under British rule, two peoples in the land each wanted a state of their own, the Jews and the Arabs. In November 1947 the United Nations voted to divide the land into a Jewish state and an Arab state. The Jewish leadership accepted the plan. The Arab leadership rejected it, calling it an injustice to the Arab majority. Fighting began the morning after the vote. When Israel declared independence in May 1948, the armies of five Arab states invaded the next day. Israel survived the war, and the Arab state was never established.