Teach Jewish History K–5 Lesson
Teacher’s Guide

Signs and Words That Hurt

What a hate symbol is, and what to do · Grades 3–5
Grade band
Grades 3–5 (K–2 version noted)
Lesson length
Around 30 minutes
Format
Board symbols · a short history told aloud · five situations
Materials
Board and marker · What I Can Do card (one per student) · the five situations in this guide, read aloud
Prerequisites
At least one lesson from the six K–5 themes, so the class meets Jewish life first
Standards
Character ed · School climate · NCSS Theme 10 (Civic Ideals and Practices) · C3 D2.Civ.7.3-5 · Common Core SL.3–5.1
Public school
Taught as history and as a class rule about how people are treated. No child is asked to speak for a group.

Why this lesson, for the teacher

Hate symbols turn up in K–12 schools. A child who draws a swastika on a desk may have copied it from an older child, a game, or a video without knowing what it means. A child who sees it may not know either, or may know and be frightened.

This lesson is meant to come before that day. It tells children in plain words what the sign is, why it frightens people, and what they can do. It gives them one question that works for any sign, word, or joke they meet later.

The swastika is described in words in this lesson. It is never drawn or shown, by the teacher or by a student.

The idea a child should leave with: If it is aimed at someone because of who they are, I don’t copy it. I find out, and I tell a grown-up.

What this lesson teaches

Students learn what a symbol is, how one old sign came to stand for hate, and why Nazi words and salutes hurt the people who hear them. By the end, a student can say why the swastika frightens people, ask whether a word or a sign is aimed at someone because of who they are, and name four safe choices.

Core understandings

  1. A symbol is a picture that stands for an idea. Most symbols help people. A few are used to frighten them.
  2. The swastika was a sign of good luck for thousands of years, and it is still a holy sign in Hindu, Buddhist, and Jain traditions. The Nazis made it their sign, and under it Germany’s government murdered six million Jews.
  3. One question tells hate apart from an opinion or a joke. Is it aimed at someone because of who they are?
  4. A child who does not know what a sign or a word means finds out before repeating it. It is always safe to ask a grown-up.
  5. A child who sees or hears hate has safe choices. Don’t copy it, tell a grown-up, and check on the classmate it was aimed at.

The words in this lesson

Suggested lesson flow

What a symbol does (4 min)

Draw a heart, a stop sign, and the recycling arrows on the board. Point to each one and ask what it means.

Say“A symbol is a picture that stands for an idea. Nobody had to read a word, and you all knew what these meant. Most symbols help us. A few are used to scare people.”
Boardsymbol = a picture that stands for an idea
One sign, told in words (7 min)

Do not draw the sign. Describe it.

Say“One of them is called the swastika. It is a cross with bent arms. For thousands of years it was a sign of good luck, and in Hindu, Buddhist, and Jain traditions it is still a holy sign.”
Say“About a hundred years ago, a political party in Germany called the Nazis took it as their sign. Their leader was Adolf Hitler. He blamed Jews for Germany’s troubles. His government took away their rights and then murdered six million Jews. It killed millions of other people too.”
Say“That is why this sign frightens people when it is drawn on a desk or a bathroom wall. It reminds Jewish families of what was done under it.”
Boardold meaning = good luck  ·  Nazi meaning = hate

A child may ask why Hitler hated Jews. A short true answer is enough. “He blamed Jews for problems they did not cause. It was a lie, and many people believed it.”

If a child asks how people were killed, say “That is history for when you are older. What matters today is that it happened, that it was wrong, and that this sign stood for it.”

Words work the same way (4 min)
Say“Some people copy the Nazis’ words too. ‘Heil Hitler’ was the Nazis’ salute to their leader. Saying it, or raising an arm the way they did, cheers for the people who did this. It is never a joke to the person who hears it.”

Keep this step short. Do not act out the salute.

The question (5 min)
BoardIs it aimed at someone because of who they are?
Say“You can ask one question about any word, joke, or drawing. Is it aimed at someone because of who they are? Their religion, their skin, the country their family comes from? If the answer is yes, it is hate, even when the person says they were only joking.”
Say“People can disagree about countries and leaders. That is allowed. Being unkind to a classmate because they are Jewish, or blaming a child for what a faraway country does, is hate. The same rule protects every child in this room.”
Find out first (3 min)
Say“Sometimes you will see a sign or hear a word and not know what it means. Find out before you repeat it, draw it, or post it. It is always safe to ask a grown-up.”

Keep that promise. A child who asks what a sign means has done what the lesson teaches, even when the sign is an ugly one. Thank them for asking.

What would you do? (6 min)

Read the situations aloud, one at a time. Take two or three answers for each, then name the choice from the card.

  • “You find a swastika scratched into the bathroom door.” Don’t add to it, and don’t try to rub it out. Tell a teacher right away.
  • “An older kid on the bus teaches your friend to say ‘Heil Hitler’ and says it’s funny.” Don’t repeat it. Tell your friend what it means. Tell a grown-up.
  • “Someone tells a Jewish classmate that a war far away is her fault.” It is aimed at her because of who she is. Tell a grown-up, and sit with her at lunch.
  • “Everyone in a game chat is posting a sign you have never seen.” Find out first. Ask a grown-up before you post it.
  • “You visit a friend’s home and see the old good-luck sign on a holiday decoration.” In a Hindu, Buddhist, or Jain home it carries its old meaning. It is not aimed at anyone.
Close (1 min)

Hand out the What I Can Do card and read the four choices together.

BoardI don’t copy it. I find out. I tell a grown-up. I check on my classmate.

The K–2 version

Ten minutes. Teach the first step, then say the lines below. Leave out the history and the card, which is written for grades 3–5.

Say“Some pictures and words are used to hurt people. If you see one, do not copy it. If you don’t know what a picture or a word means, ask a grown-up. Then be kind to the child it was aimed at.”

If a K–2 child has drawn a swastika, say “That sign has been used to hurt Jewish people, and it scares people who see it. We don’t draw it.” Then ask where they saw it.

Notes on teaching this well

If it has already happened

These steps are adapted for younger children from the Anti-Defamation League’s guide for responding to bias incidents in schools.

  1. Stop it calmly and ask what the child knows. A young child may not know what the sign means, so explain it privately.
  2. Photograph it and report it to the principal. Then have it removed.
  3. Check privately on the child it was aimed at. Ask how you can help.
  4. Teach this lesson to the whole class. Do not present it as a punishment.
  5. With the principal, tell families what happened and what the class learned. Name no child.

The Hate Symbols page lists where to report an incident beyond the school.

Follow-up, pairing & sources

Tell us how it went

Teachers and administrators, please share your experience at education@teachjewishhistory.org. A few sentences on what worked and what did not will improve the lesson. With your permission, your words may be shared so the next teacher knows what to expect.