The Continuous Jewish Presence in the Land
teachjewishhistory.org/topic-continuous-presence
A quick drop-in, about 15 minutes. No background needed. Larger lessons are linked at the end.
Words to know with Israeli pronunciation
- Nachmanides nakh-MAH-nee-des A rabbi and physician from Catalonia, in Spain.
- Torah toh-RAH The first five books of the Hebrew Bible.
Jewish communities pronounce Hebrew in different ways, so a student may know another version. The kh is the sound at the end of Bach.
Open
The short version says the Jews left their land in the year 70 and came back in 1948. What happened in the eighteen centuries between?
The story
Rome destroyed the Temple, the central Jewish sanctuary in Jerusalem, in 70 CE. Modern Israel was founded in 1948. Jewish communities lived in the land through all eighteen centuries between. Across every ruling power, the number of Jews in the land rose and fell, in Jerusalem at times to a few households, but the presence never broke.
Read together
In 1267 the Catalan rabbi and physician Nachmanides reached Jerusalem at about seventy-three and found the city devastated. In a letter to his son he described what was left of its Jews:
“only two brothers, dyers who bought their dye from the governor”
Within weeks he had founded a synagogue in a ruined house, and Torah scrolls, the handwritten scrolls of the Bible’s first five books, were brought back from where they had been sent for safety. Jewish life in Jerusalem revived around him.
Today
Today Israel is home to about 45 percent of the world’s Jews.
Discuss
Find it in the reading
How many Jews did Nachmanides find in Jerusalem in 1267, and what did he do next?
Answer: Two brothers, who worked as dyers. Within weeks he had founded a synagogue.
Talk about it There is no single right answer.
What does it take for a community to count as present in a place?
Discussion points
- The numbers rose and fell. In Jerusalem it was at times a few households.
- Nachmanides needed only two people and a ruined house to start a synagogue.
- The rulers changed many times. The same small communities are recorded under each of them.
To close
What we saw. Between the year 70 and 1948, Jews were living in the land in every century, under every ruler.
To carry into the unit. As each empire in the course takes this land, who was already living there?
When to use it
When you teach Rome, the Islamic empires, the Crusades, or the Ottoman Empire. Each of them ruled this land.
Larger lessons
This is a quick drop-in. When you have more time:
- The full Chapter, The Continuous Jewish Presence in the Land, with discussion questions and Classroom Connections.
- The Teaching Guides, by course.

