Teach Jewish HistoryTeach Jewish HistoryTEACH JEWISH HISTORY Translate · via Google Español Français Deutsch Italiano Português עברית العربية Русский 中文 Text size

For Teachers › 15-minute lessons

The Afterlife of the ImageA 15-minute lesson

The lesson
Unit 6 · Ch. 08Recommended for · Grades 9–12 · College Courses

The Afterlife of the Image

teachjewishhistory.org/topic-afterlife-image

A quick drop-in, about 15 minutes. No background needed. Larger lessons are linked at the end.

Words to know and how to say them

  • relief A carving that stands out from a wall.
  • recontextualize To explain an object where it stands, so that it is read as a warning.

Open

On the wall of a church in Germany there is a medieval carving made to insult Jews. The church is still in use. A court was asked to order the carving taken down and declined. What should be done with it?

The story

Across Germany, and in a few places beyond it, medieval carvings made to insult Jews are still fixed to churches that are in use today. Such a carving is both a standing insult to a living people and evidence of how antisemitism was taught. Three kinds of answer recur: explain the object where it stands, reject the idea behind it, and refute the lie when it returns.

Read together

German courts, up to the Federal Court of Justice in 2022, declined to order one such carving taken down. That court described it as antisemitism

“carved in stone.”

It found, however, that the parish had distanced itself from the carving through a memorial and an explanatory text on the site, which present it as a warning.

Read it in the Chapter

The pattern

Dehumanized. Jews are mocked, or shown as animals or monsters, not people. Here the image is still on the wall. The Recurring Cycle chart follows it from the ancient world to today.

Discuss

Find it in the reading

What did the court call the carving, and why did it let it stay?

Answer: Antisemitism “carved in stone.” It stayed because the parish had added a memorial and an explanation that present it as a warning.

Talk about it There is no single right answer.

Three answers recur: explain the object where it stands, reject the idea behind it, and refute the lie when it returns. Which would you choose for this carving, and why?

Discussion points
  • Removing it hides the evidence of how the hatred was taught.
  • Leaving it without comment repeats the insult every day.
  • The court accepted a third way: keep it, and explain it.

If there is time

Compare the carving to one modern example: a Soviet statue, a colonial figure, or a Confederate monument. What makes the choices alike, and what makes them different?

To close

What we saw. A medieval carving made to insult Jews is still on a church wall, now with a memorial and an explanation beside it.

To carry into the unit. Which monuments in the history you are studying are being argued over today?

When to use it

When you teach medieval Europe, or public memory and monuments.

Larger lessons

This is a quick drop-in. When you have more time:

Show on the board

Keep going

Last updated: November 2026.