American Jewry
teachjewishhistory.org/topic-american-jewry
A quick drop-in, about 15 minutes. No background needed. Larger lessons are linked at the end.
Words to know and how to say them
- Seixas SAY-shus Warden of the Newport synagogue in 1790.
- toleration Being allowed, as a favor.
Open
In 1790 the president of a new country wrote to a small synagogue in Rhode Island. He told its members that their freedom was a right, not a favor. Has the country kept that promise?
The story
American Jewish history is one community arriving in waves, each from a different corner of the Jewish world. It also shows one principle being tested again and again: whether a country built on religious liberty would extend it to a small and visible minority. Within three years of the first landing in 1654, Jews had argued and won their first civil-rights fights in America. In 1915 a mob in Georgia lynched Leo Frank, a Jewish factory manager. In the 1920s Harvard and other colleges limited Jewish admissions. In 2018 a gunman killed eleven worshippers at the Tree of Life synagogue in Pittsburgh.
Read together
In 1790 Moses Seixas, warden of the Hebrew Congregation of Newport, welcomed President George Washington by praising
“a Government, which to bigotry gives no sanction, to persecution no assistance.”
Washington’s reply took up the phrase and went further:
“It is now no more that toleration is spoken of, as if it was by the indulgence of one class of people, that another enjoyed the exercise of their inherent natural rights.”
In plain words: religious freedom is a right every citizen already has. It is not a favor the majority grants.
Discuss
Find it in the reading
According to Washington, what is wrong with the word toleration?
Answer: It treats freedom as a favor that one group grants another. He calls religious liberty an inherent natural right.
Talk about it There is no single right answer.
Choose one event from the story. Was the 1790 promise kept or broken there, and how do you know?
Discussion points
- 1654 to 1657: Jews argued for their rights and won. Kept.
- Leo Frank in 1915, and college quotas in the 1920s. Broken.
- Tree of Life, 2018: the attacker was a gunman, not the government. Ask whether that breaks the promise.
To close
What we saw. In 1790 the first president told a small synagogue that freedom of religion was a right, and the promise has been tested ever since.
To carry into the unit. In the unit you are studying now, was that promise being kept?
When to use it
In a U.S. history course, when you teach the founding, immigration, the 1920s, or civil rights.
Larger lessons
This is a quick drop-in. When you have more time:
- The full Chapter, American Jewry, with discussion questions and Classroom Connections.
- The Teaching Guides, by course.

