Hannah Arendt
teachjewishhistory.org/topic-arendt
A quick drop-in, about 15 minutes. No background needed. Larger lessons are linked at the end.
Words to know and how to say them
- Arendt AH-rent A German-Jewish philosopher who fled the Nazis.
- banality bah-NAL-ih-tee Ordinariness.
- Eichmann IKE-mahn The SS officer who organized the deportations.
Open
Adolf Eichmann organized the deportations to the killing centers. In the courtroom he looked like a clerk. Which is more frightening, a monster or a clerk?
The story
The philosopher Hannah Arendt reported on the Eichmann trial for The New Yorker. She argued that the man in the glass booth was an ordinary functionary rather than a monster. She did not argue that this made him less guilty. Her phrase for it, “the banality of evil,” became one of the most argued-over of the twentieth century. Later research on Eichmann’s own writings showed that he was a committed Nazi.
Read together
Arendt ends her book with the judgment she would have had the court give Eichmann:
“This is the reason, and the only reason, you must hang.”
In plain words: she called him ordinary, and she still held him fully guilty.
The connection
The lesson fits any unit on the Holocaust, on ethics, or on how ordinary people take part in the crimes of a state.
Discuss
Find it in the reading
What judgment does Arendt give Eichmann at the end of her book?
Answer: That he must hang. She held him fully guilty.
Talk about it There is no single right answer.
From the story, what exactly did Arendt claim about Eichmann, and what did her critics say she got wrong?
Discussion points
- She argued that he was an ordinary official, not a monster, and still guilty.
- Critics said she underrated his hatred. Later research on his own writings showed a committed Nazi.
- Ask which matters more for preventing such crimes: watching for monsters, or watching for officials who obey.
If there is time
Later research showed that Eichmann was a committed Nazi. Does that weaken Arendt’s argument, or only her example?
To close
What we saw. Arendt described the organizer of the deportations as an ordinary official, and she held him fully guilty.
To carry into the unit. In the history you are studying, who carried out the orders?
When to use it
When you teach essays and nonfiction, ethics, or the Holocaust.
Larger lessons
This is a quick drop-in. When you have more time:
- The full Chapter, Hannah Arendt, with discussion questions and Classroom Connections.
- The Teaching Guides, by course.

