Old Lies, New Words
teachjewishhistory.org/for-tomorrow#lesson-topic-old-lies-new-words
A quick drop-in, about 15 minutes. No background needed. Larger lessons are linked at the end.
Words to know and how to say them
- Zionism The movement for a Jewish state in the Land of Israel.
- anti-Zionism Opposition to that idea.
Open
In 1975 the UN General Assembly declared that Zionism, the movement for a Jewish homeland, was “a form of racism.” In 1991 the same body took it back, 111 to 25. How do you tell a criticism of a government from an old lie in new words?
The story
Antisemitism rarely invents itself from scratch. It reaches for a small set of very old myths and dresses them for the moment: the Jew as poisoner, as conspirator, as disloyal outsider, as secret power behind events. What changes is the costume and the delivery. Three widely used definitions of antisemitism all protect criticism of Israel’s policies, leaders, and laws. All three treat the old charges as antisemitism when they come back under a new name.
Read together
Then and now, from the Chapters.
Norwich, England, 1144
Jews are accused of murdering a child for a ritual.
Today: cartoons and posts accuse Israel of stealing the organs of Palestinians. The Anti-Defamation League traces them to the medieval charge.
Russia, 1903
A forged book says Jews secretly control governments and the press.
Today: the same claim is made about banks, the news, Hollywood, and governments.
The pattern
Accused, then Spread. The charge is old. The carrier is new. The Recurring Cycle chart follows it from the ancient world to today.
Discuss
Find it in the reading
Put one question to each statement: is it about a government’s policies, or is it an old lie about Jews in a new costume? “Israel should change its policy in the West Bank.” “Israelis take the organs of Palestinians.” “Jews control Hollywood and the news.” “Jewish students here should answer for what Israel does.”
Answer: The first is about a policy. The second is the blood libel. The third is the secret-control charge of the Protocols. The fourth blames a whole people for what a government does.
Talk about it There is no single right answer.
Which were easy to sort, and which took an argument?
Discussion points
- The first names a policy and says it should change. That is ordinary political speech.
- The middle two are old charges with a new target.
- The last holds people responsible for a government they do not run.
To close
What we saw. Three of the four statements repeat a charge that is centuries old. One is about a policy.
To carry into the unit. When the news comes up in this course, which kind of statement are you hearing?
When to use it
When the news comes into the room, in any course.
Larger lessons
This is a quick drop-in. When you have more time:
- The full class period, planned for you, with the sorting sheet.
- The full Chapter, Contemporary Antisemitism, with discussion questions and Classroom Connections.
- The Teaching Guides, by course.

