Teach Jewish HistoryTeach Jewish HistoryTEACH JEWISH HISTORY Translate · via Google Español Français Deutsch Italiano Português עברית العربية Русский 中文 Text size

Who was allowed to belong?

For most of two thousand years, Jews lived as a minority almost everywhere they lived, often in the same place for centuries. Today they are the majority in one country, Israel, and a minority everywhere else.

This chart follows one people, the Jews, through thirteen societies. Each one set its own terms, and each row shows how those terms compared with everyone else’s. Find the unit you teach, and set its answer beside the others.

Where and whenThe terms for JewsWhat that meantChapter
Persian Empire, 500s BCEAllowed to return and rebuildBabylon had conquered the kingdom of Judah and carried many of its people into exile. When the Persian king Cyrus conquered Babylon, he let them go home and rebuild their Temple in Jerusalem.Everyone else Jews were not singled out. Cyrus sent other peoples home as well. A clay cylinder inscribed in his name, now in the British Museum, says he returned them to their homes and restored their temples.The First and Second Temples
Roman Empire, after 70 CEAllowed to remain, under a special taxRome destroyed the Temple in Jerusalem in 70 CE. The emperor then ordered every Jew in the empire to pay a yearly tax to a Roman temple.Everyone else No other people in the empire paid this tax.Adversus Judaeos
Lands under Islamic rule, for twelve centuriesProtected, on second-class termsIslamic law protected their lives, property, and worship. In exchange they paid a special tax and accepted a lower legal rank. The arrangement is called the dhimma, Arabic for “pact.” Enforcement varied by ruler and century. Under it Jewish learning flourished in Baghdad and Córdoba, and under it came the Granada massacre of 1066.Everyone else Muslims did not pay the tax, and converting to Islam ended the status. The same terms covered Christians and Zoroastrians, who followed the old religion of Persia.The Dhimma
Medieval Christian kingdoms, to 1492Protected as the king’s own, then expelledJews belonged directly to the king. He protected them and could tax them as he pleased. Between 1290 and 1492, England, France, and Spain each ordered their entire Jewish population to leave. In Spain, Jews had lived for more than a thousand years.Everyone else Other subjects answered to a town or a lord. The craft guilds were Christian bodies with no place for Jews, and land law in much of Europe required a Christian oath. Spain’s Muslims faced the same choice, conversion or exile, ten years later.The Expulsions
Poland and Lithuania, 1264 to 1764Protected by charter, and self-governingKings and princes issued written charters that promised protection in return for taxes and trade. Jewish communities ran their own affairs through their own councils.Everyone else Jews stood apart in law from the Christian townspeople. In 1670 the townspeople and the Jews of Tarnów signed their own agreement on taxes and trade.The Jews of Poland and Lithuania
Italian and central European cities, from 1516Allowed to stay, inside a walled quarterJews had to live in one enclosed part of the city. Venice gave it the name ghetto in 1516, and Rome followed in 1555.Everyone else The rule applied to Jews alone. They could leave only during set daylight hours, and they had to pay the Christian guards who locked the gates at night.The Ghetto System
The United States, 1790A right, not a favorPresident George Washington wrote to the Jewish congregation of Newport, Rhode Island, that religious liberty was a right every citizen held: “It is now no more that toleration is spoken of, as if it was by the indulgence of one class of people, that another enjoyed the exercise of their inherent natural rights.”Everyone else The same letter says, “All possess alike liberty of conscience and immunities of citizenship.” That year, the first naturalization law, which set who could become a citizen, opened citizenship to an immigrant who was “a free white person,” and slavery was legal.American Jewry
France, 1791Full citizensDuring the French Revolution, the National Assembly voted to make Jews full citizens. France was the first European state to do so.Everyone else The same citizenship as other French citizens. In 1806 Napoleon still summoned Jewish leaders to Paris with questions about their loyalty.Moses Mendelssohn
Russian Empire, 1791 to 1917Confined by law to one regionJews were permitted to live, with narrow exceptions, only in the empire’s western provinces, an area called the Pale of Settlement. Within it they were barred from certain cities.Everyone else The rule applied to Jews alone. For them, living outside the Pale was forbidden.The Russian Pogroms
Nazi Germany, 1935Citizenship taken away by lawGerman Jews had been equal citizens since 1871. About 100,000 served in the German army in the First World War, and about 12,000 were killed fighting for Germany. The hatred was older than the laws. From the 1870s a movement had argued that Jews were a separate race and that giving them equal rights had been a mistake. After Germany’s defeat in 1918 and the Depression, a party built on that idea took power in 1933. In 1935 a law divided people into full citizens and “state subjects.” Only those “of German or related blood” could be citizens, so German Jews lost their citizenship. The mass murder came after six years of laws like this one. Six million European Jews were murdered.Everyone else Other Germans stayed citizens with full rights. The regime soon applied the same racial rules to Black Germans and to the Roma and Sinti, the Romani peoples living in Germany.The Years Before the Killing
Soviet UnionCitizens, with Jewish life shut downJews were citizens, but the state shut down organized Jewish life. People who applied to leave the country paid with their jobs and sometimes their freedom.Everyone else In 1962 Jews were about one percent of the population and 54 percent of those sentenced to death for “economic crimes.” Stalin had earlier deported whole nationalities, among them the Chechens, Crimean Tatars, and Volga Germans.Soviet Jewry
Arab countries, 1945 to 1972Citizenship stripped, property seizedJewish communities had lived in these countries for centuries, in Iraq for more than 2,500 years. Governments in several countries stripped citizenship, seized property, or ordered expulsions. About 850,000 Jews left or were forced out.Everyone else The measures were directed at Jews. In Iraq, a Jew who left had to give up citizenship, and in 1951 the government froze the property of those who had.The Departure from MENA
Israel, since 1948The one country where Jews are the majorityNearly half the world’s Jews live in Israel today. The Law of Return (1950) gives any Jew the right to immigrate and become a citizen.Everyone else Arab citizens are the largest minority. They hold the same citizenship and the same vote as Jewish citizens. They sit in the Knesset, Israel’s parliament, and have served as government ministers and Supreme Court judges. The state was founded in a war that ended in cease-fire lines, not peace treaties. Until 1966 the army, not civilian officials, governed border areas where many Arab citizens lived, on grounds of security, and leaving those areas required a permit. The government ended the system that year, saying security could be kept without it. In 2003 a state commission found that governments had neglected Arab communities and had not shared state resources equally. Since 2015 the government has adopted two five-year plans to narrow those gaps. The West Bank and Gaza are a separate case, covered in the Chapter.The Modern State of Israel

Three sources beyond the Chapters. The Cyrus Cylinder: The British Museum. The 1790 naturalization law: Act of March 26, 1790, 1 Stat. 103, govinfo.gov. Israel’s five-year plans: Israel Democracy Institute, 2019 and 2021.

A question for the classWhich of these terms could a ruler take back, and which could not?

Last updated: November 2026.